Better in Australia?

England last won an Ashes Test in Australia in 2010/11  since when  0-13. After the 2021/22 series a  review  pointed to a quantity problem with domestic cricket: there’s too much of it.  For every team sheet in Australia’s red-ball competition, the Sheffield Shield, there are four in the Championship, allow  for  the number of players, the weather and there is a  noticeable difference  in the playing days for individual players.

The Sheffield Shield is played almost entirely by Australians,  arguably making it  more focussed,  intense with  the influence of  Test players, past and present, greater. Possibly, although  when it comes to Test cricketers the  Championship with its openess scales up pretty well, and with these numbers also reasonable to ask why isn’t domestic cricket a sizeable advantage to England? Maybe it is of course, just not obviously  given a legacy of  spending big on buildings and not giving enough for  the playing base.

When Joe Root tossed up at the Gabba in 2021 he was starting his 13th Test that year, Pat Cummins his third, and England’s players continue to play on more days  because England continues to play more Tests; an average of 75 days to the Australians 61 in 2024(/5). No doubting either how reliant England’s Test team has been  on those who play the most, almost half the names on  team sheets those who had a schedule of 100 days plus. A too much problem, but £, Sky, T20 leagues and market forces; or,  actually okay, England’s best in demand and just doing what they should be doing?

Going from year to season the number of playing days for English players, averaging 75 and 39, is in proportion. Some variation between the counties certainly, different numbers of players, how much white-ball they play etc, but  not a  concentration of smaller counties near the top of the table. Plainly other Test nations put out competitive teams with fewer domestic players, but in England, starting from here, it’s not obvious that contraction below would result in an advance above.

 

Data compiled from Cricket Archive.